Classroom skills · Article

Eliciting in ELT: Stop Playing “Guess What's in My Head”

Make eliciting useful: ask questions learners can answer, allow thinking time, distinguish eliciting from CCQs and know when direct explanation is better.

By Ahmed Bin Nasser, CELTA Main Course Tutor · · Last updated

Asking questions isn't automatically student-centred. Sometimes it's just a longer way of saying what you wanted to say.

T: What's the word for a person who does dangerous scenes instead of an actor?

L: An athlete?

T: No… something else?

L: A driver?

T: Almost. It begins with S.

L: A… stunt?

T: Yes! Stunt double. Excellent!

(An illustrative exchange.) Let's assume this class has never met the expression stunt double.

Before you read on: what did that exchange achieve?

We spent a minute pulling out an answer learners had almost no reasonable basis for. That isn't learner-centred. It's a guessing game where only the teacher knows the secret word.

I value elicitation. Used well, it activates knowledge, generates ideas, shows understanding, and gives learners a real role in building the lesson. But eliciting is not an obligation to make learners guess every word you could explain in ten seconds.

What is elicitation, and why use it?

Elicitation means using a question, prompt, picture, context or other stimulus to invite learners to supply ideas, information, language or an interpretation.

It can do different jobs:

  • Find out
    • what learners already know
    • evidence during feedback
  • Generate
  • Push thinking
    • recognising a pattern
    • self-correction
Six jobs a question can do. Every elicitation should have one.

These purposes matter, because an elicitation can "work" (someone gives the expected answer) without doing much for learning.

If you ask Is he happy? and learners say Yes, what have you learned? Maybe something. Maybe almost nothing, if the answer was obvious.

The first question: can learners reasonably answer?

Before you try to elicit a word or structure, ask yourself: have learners met it before, or can they work it out from what you're giving them?

Illustrative scenario: learners have just read a story about a missed flight. You want delayed.

What's another word for late, beginning with D? The flight was delayed by two hours. Did it leave on time?

Careful: the second question checks understanding. It doesn't elicit the word delayed. If learners probably know the word, a good prompt might elicit it. If not, give it clearly and use the context to establish its meaning, pronunciation and form.

There's nothing shameful about telling learners something new. That's part of teaching.

  • Have learners met this language before?Yes → give a clear retrieval cue (context, picture, "Which expression did we use yesterday?"). Elicit it.No → go to the next question.
  • Can they work it out from the context you give?Yes → let them inspect the evidence, then elicit their idea.No → supply it. Model it in context, then check meaning and pronunciation.
  • Did the question give you real evidence?Yes → move on.No → it was a guess. Check with a better question, such as a concept-checking question.
Elicit or supply? Decide before you ask.

Elicit knowledge, not telepathy

Compare these question types.

Question typeExampleWhy it can work
Open the discussionWhat problems might someone have when working from home?Many answers are possible. The point is ideas, not a secret answer.
Retrieve familiar languageWhich expression did we use yesterday to make a polite request?Learners have prior experience and a clear cue.
Explore a patternWhich words seem to introduce a reason? (after several examples)Learners can inspect evidence and compare ideas.
Guess my wordWhat am I thinking of? Nine letters, starts with P.It rarely does. A right answer tells you little and may leave quieter learners out.
Try this: an A2 class meets run out of for the first time, with no context. You need them to understand We've run out of milk. Elicit or explain?

Use a short, meaningful situation or picture: an empty milk carton and someone who wants tea. Establish that there's no milk left, give the phrase clearly, then check meaning and pronunciation. If learners already recognise the phrase, you can invite them to supply it. Don't stretch the lesson with unsupported guessing.

The mistake teachers make with CCQs and elicitation

These two are related, but not interchangeable.

Elicitation gets an idea, a word, a prediction or a response. Concept-checking questions (CCQs) collect evidence that learners understand the meaning of the target language.

Say you're clarifying He used to work nights.

What tense is this? Was working nights a past habit? Does the sentence tell us he still does it?

"What tense is this?" may be a language-analysis question, but it doesn't show whether learners understand the idea of a past habit or state.

One caution: used to usually suggests the situation is over, but a flat "Does he work nights now? Definitely not" may be too strong for every reading. Better to design the context so the contrast is clear.

Wait time changes whose thinking counts

Some teachers ask a question and name a learner before anyone has had time to think. Others ask, pause for less than a second, and answer their own question.

Before you read on: how long do you usually wait after a question? Guess, honestly.

Most of us wait less than we think. Mary Budd Rowe's research on wait time (Rowe, 1974) showed why pauses, both after a question and after a learner's answer, are worth thinking about. Her work was in science classrooms, so it isn't a fixed ELT timing rule. But if a question really needs thought, give that thought a moment.

  1. AskOne clear question.
  2. PauseGive thinking time before anyone answers.
  3. NominateChoose a learner fairly, or let pairs compare first.
  4. ListenHear the whole answer. Pause again.
  5. Follow upBuild on it: "Why?", "Anyone different?"
A useful routine, not a ritual for every question. A casual chat may not need nomination; a quick instruction check may not need a long pause.

Your tone matters as much as your timing. A partly correct answer needs a response that invites more thinking, not a public interrogation. For example (illustrative):

L: He go to London yesterday.

T: Yesterday — yes. Have a look at the verb.

L: Oh. He went to London yesterday.

That prompt works if the learner already knows the past form. If she doesn't, give it. Saying Are you sure? four times rarely produces better learning. (See error correction: now or later? and scaffolding vs spoon-feeding for how far to push.)

Don't let two confident learners become the whole class

Elicitation sounds student-centred because learners are speaking. But if the same two volunteers answer every time, everyone else just watches.

Small adjustments help:

  • give individual thinking time before an open-class question;
  • let learners compare a choice in pairs first;
  • nominate fairly, and never as a punishment;
  • accept more than one sensible idea when the question really is open;
  • invite a quieter learner to build on a partner's answer, rather than perform alone.

Question lab: which would you use, and for what?

A. "What's the word for this, beginning with R?"

An efficient retrieval cue if learners know the word. A frustrating guessing game if it's new.

B. "Which sentence shows a completed past action? What tells you?"

Learners have evidence they can inspect, so it supports analysis.

C. "What could the character do next?"

It generates possibilities: good before reading or as a discussion question.

Decide first, then tap. None is good outside its context: purpose and learner readiness decide.

Now, what would you do next? Take question A and rewrite it for a class meeting the word for the first time.

Elicitation during different lesson stages

StageElicitation can…Watch out for…
Lead-indraw out experiences, predictions and opinionsa hidden test of grammar they haven't learned yet
Language clarificationget known meanings or forms from a clear context; CCQs check meaningeliciting what learners can't know: explain instead
Task feedbackexplore disagreements and reasoningreading every answer from every pair; show a key for simple items
Error correctiona short prompt invites self-repairrepeated prompting when the learner doesn't know the form
Reflection"Which part of that strategy helped?" "What would you do differently?"questions with no time to answer properly

The lead-in article shows how to use that stage without teaching the target language too early, and feedback after tasks shows where open-class questioning earns its time.

Why some elicitation feels uncomfortable

A long teacher–learner question chain can become a row of tiny tests, each answer judged at once. Discourse analysts describe this as the IRF pattern: the teacher Initiates, a learner Responds, the teacher gives Follow-up (Sinclair & Coulthard, 1975).

IRF is not bad in itself. It organises classroom talk well. The problem comes when it leaves no room for learners to explain, disagree or build ideas together.

Try changing the follow-up:

Correct. Next question. What in the text made you think that? Does anyone have a different reason?

But don't manufacture a discussion for a question with one simple factual answer. That wastes time too. (Wells, 1999, explores how teachers can make that follow-up move more dialogic.)

For CELTA and DELTA teachers

On CELTA, tutors want to see that your questions help learners understand, engage and take part. Clear explanation, appropriate elicitation and accurate concept checking are tools, not trophies you collect in teaching practice.

On DELTA, think about the bigger rationale. Does the elicitation access prior knowledge? Does it give a reason to process input? Are the questions valid evidence of the intended learning? Is the amount of teacher-led questioning justified by the aim? (Keep an eye on teacher talking time too: long question chains are still teacher talk.)

I'd rather see a teacher explain something accurately in twenty seconds than spend three minutes performing student-centredness that leaves everyone confused.

Try it tomorrow

Choose three questions from your next lesson plan. Beside each, write what it is for and how a learner could reasonably answer it.

While teaching, don't answer too quickly. Listen to what learners actually say. If the information isn't accessible to them, supply it and move on.

Don't measure elicitation by whether you got the word. Measure it by whether the question helped learners think, communicate or understand.

Quick FAQs

Is elicitation always better than explanation?

No. Explanation may be better when the knowledge is new or the prompt doesn't give learners enough to work with.

What's the difference between elicitation and CCQs?

Elicitation invites information or language. CCQs specifically check understanding of meaning.

Do I need to nominate after every question?

No. Use nomination to manage participation when it helps, not as a ritual.

How long should I wait?

Long enough for a meaningful response, given the question and the learners. Research on wait time supports pausing, but no single duration suits every ELT classroom moment.

Keep learning with Lumina

References

  • Cambridge English. CELTA syllabus and assessment guidelines. cambridgeenglish.org
  • Long, M. H., & Sato, C. J. (1983). Classroom foreigner talk discourse: Forms and functions of teachers' questions. In H. W. Seliger & M. H. Long (Eds.), Classroom Oriented Research in Second Language Acquisition (pp. 268–285). Newbury House.
  • Lyster, R., & Ranta, L. (1997). Corrective feedback and learner uptake. Studies in Second Language Acquisition, 19(1), 37–66. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0272263197001034
  • Rowe, M. B. (1974). Reflections on wait-time: Some methodological questions. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 11(3), 263–279. https://doi.org/10.1002/tea.3660110309
  • Sinclair, J. McH., & Coulthard, R. M. (1975). Towards an Analysis of Discourse. Oxford University Press.
  • Walsh, S. (2011). Exploring Classroom Discourse: Language in Action. Routledge.
  • Wells, G. (1999). Dialogic Inquiry. Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511605895

Check your understanding

6 short questions. No account needed, no score, and nothing you choose or write is saved or sent anywhere.

  1. 1 Learners have never met an unfamiliar lexical item. They cannot infer it from the available context. What next?
    Show the answer (no automatic checking)

    Answer: B. Elicitation cannot retrieve unavailable knowledge.

    By Lumina Trainers

  2. 2 Which is the clearest example of a meaning CCQ rather than general elicitation?
    Show the answer (no automatic checking)

    Answer: C. It targets a meaning distinction relevant to a specified language item.

    By Lumina Trainers

  3. 3 Why can wait time help after a challenging question?
    Show the answer (no automatic checking)

    Answer: B. A purposeful pause can broaden thinking opportunities; outcomes still vary.

    By Lumina Trainers

  4. 4 True or false: Eliciting all target language is mandatory in effective CELTA lessons.
    Show the answer (no automatic checking)

    Answer: B. The choice between eliciting and explaining depends on learners and task purpose.

    By Lumina Trainers

  5. 5 Match each teaching situation with the most appropriate response.
    • A CCQ
    • B Brainstorm elicitation
    • C Retrieval prompt
    Show the answer (no automatic checking)

    Answer: 1–B, 2–A, 3–C. Compare the learning need and the purpose of the response; there is no benefit in using one routine for every situation.

    By Lumina Trainers

  6. 6 A teacher asks six leading questions before supplying an entirely new expression. Suggest a better route.

    Show a suggested answer

    Establish a relevant context, make the unknown expression available through a concise model or explanation, check meaning and pronunciation, and give learners meaningful practice. Reserve elicitation for knowledge they can reasonably retrieve or infer.

    Suggested answer by Lumina Trainers

Ahmed Bin NasserCELTA Tutor & Teacher Trainer | Lumina