Classroom skills · Article

Feedback after a lesson: how trainers give it, and how to use it to improve

اقرأ هذه المقالة بالعربية Read this in Arabic

How post-lesson feedback works on CELTA and TEFL teaching practice: self-evaluation, trainer criteria, strengths and action points, written feedback, peer feedback, and how to act on it.

By Ahmed Bin Nasser, CELTA Main Course Tutor · · Last updated

The lesson ends. You collect your materials with slightly shaking hands, sit down with the trainer and the other trainees, and the first thing you hear is not a verdict. It is a question: "So, how do you think it went?"

For many new teachers, that question is harder than the lesson. But it is the start of the most useful forty minutes on any teacher training course. After observing hundreds of teaching practices, the pattern I see is consistent: the teachers who improve fastest are not the ones who taught the best first lesson. They are the ones who could hear feedback, pick one thing, and change it by the following lesson.

This guide explains how post-lesson feedback works on CELTA and practical TEFL courses, what trainers are looking for, and how to turn feedback into a better next lesson.

What is post-lesson feedback for?

Post-lesson feedback is a structured conversation after an observed lesson that helps the teacher see what happened, understand why, and agree one or two specific changes for the next lesson. It is not a verdict on the teacher, and it is not a list of everything that happened.

Its purpose is simple: the next lesson should be better than this one in a way the teacher can name.

The feedback cycle

  1. Self-evaluation.The teacher speaks first: what worked, what did not, and why.
  2. Evidence.Trainer and peers add what they saw and heard, with specific moments.
  3. Action points.One or two changes, agreed and written in the teacher's own words.
  4. Next plan.The action points go into the next lesson plan, at the stage where they apply.
A simple cycle from one lesson to the next. The last step is the one most often forgotten.

Why self-evaluation comes first

On a well-run course, the trainer does not speak first. The teacher does. A teacher who can see their own lesson accurately will keep improving after the course ends, when there is no trainer in the room. A teacher who cannot will depend on someone else's eyes.

So before you hear anything, write three lines: one thing that worked and why, one thing that did not and why, and one thing you would do differently. Be specific. "The pair work was good" tells you nothing. "Pairs talked for four minutes without me, and I heard the target language in three of them" is a real observation.

What trainers look at: the criteria

Feedback on a serious course is not personal taste. It is measured against criteria that are public and the same for everyone. On CELTA, the assessment criteria cover planning, teaching and professional development, and in practice trainers look at questions like these:

  • Aims. Were the aims clear and achieved? Could learners do something at the end they could not do at the start?
  • Clarifying language. Was meaning, form and pronunciation clear, and was understanding checked, for example with concept checking questions?
  • Instructions and teacher talk. Were instructions short and checked? Was teacher talking time purposeful?
  • Learner engagement. Were learners working, speaking and thinking, or mostly listening and waiting?
  • Monitoring and error correction. Did the teacher listen during tasks and deal with useful errors?
  • Staging and timing. Did stages follow logically from the lesson plan, and was the final stage given enough time?

Lumina's Practical TEFL is CELTA-based and uses the same criteria in its teaching practice, because they describe what a good lesson looks like regardless of who is assessing it.

Strengths and action points

Good feedback names strengths precisely, because a strength you cannot name is one you might lose next week. "Your instructions for the reading task were eleven words and you demonstrated before they started" is useful. "Good energy" is not.

Then come the action points. The rule experienced trainers follow, and that trainees should hold them to, is one or two things to work on. Not six. A list of six is complete and useless, because nobody can change six habits in a week. If the lesson had ten problems, the trainer's job is to find the one or two that caused most of the others. Often it is instructions, or planning, or the teacher answering their own questions. Fix that one, and three other problems disappear with it.

Vague feedbackUseful feedback
Work on your instructions.Your instructions for the speaking task were about a minute long and learners asked what to do. Next time: write them in under fifteen words, demonstrate with one learner, then ask "Alone or in pairs?"
Check understanding more.After presenting used to, nobody was asked whether it is true now. Plan two CCQs, one of which checks "now".
Less TTT.You repeated nine learner answers in the feedback stage. In the next lesson, react without repeating, or ask another learner to respond.

Oral and written feedback

Oral feedback happens soon after the lesson, usually with the other trainees present. It is a conversation: the teacher's self-evaluation, the trainer's questions, some discussion, and the action points agreed out loud.

Written feedback comes afterwards and should match what was said. It is the record. Keep it. Before your next lesson, read the last two sets of written feedback and check your plan against the action points. If the same point appears three times in a row, that is the only thing you need to work on.

How to take feedback, and act on it

  • Listen to the end before replying. The urge to explain why something happened is strong, and it stops you hearing the next sentence.
  • Ask for the example. "When did I echo?" is a good question. "I don't think I echo" is not.
  • Write the action points in your own words, in the plan for the next lesson, at the stage where they apply.
  • Change one thing at a time and let the trainer see it. The second lesson is where many trainees show the biggest jump, not because they are better teachers yet, but because they acted on one point.
  • Separate the lesson from yourself. Feedback is about decisions you made in one lesson, all of which can be made differently next time.

Peer feedback

Watching other trainees teach, and giving them feedback, is half the learning on a course. Use the same shape: what worked, with an example, then one thing to consider. Stay with what you saw and heard, not what you would have done. The point of peer feedback is not to be kind or to be harsh. It is to be accurate, in a way the other person can use.

A useful structure for peers: "I noticed... (a specific moment). The effect on learners was... (what happened). Next time you could try... (one suggestion)."

Feedback that builds reflection, not defence

The quickest way to make a teacher defensive is to tell them what they did wrong before they have had a chance to say it themselves. The quickest way to build reflection is to ask. "What did the learners do during the first three minutes?" "How many of them spoke before you did?" Questions like these make the teacher look at the lesson rather than at the trainer.

The same principle applies when you give feedback to learners on their language. The free guide Open-class feedback that teaches, in the YALA ELT Community library, is about that side of the classroom: correcting learners after a task in a way that teaches the whole class rather than embarrassing one person.

After the course: keep the cycle going

The trainer leaves when the course ends; the cycle does not have to. Record ten minutes of a lesson once a month, write your three lines, choose one action point, and put it in your next plan. Ask a colleague to observe one stage with a single question in mind. Teachers who keep this habit continue improving long after their certificate is framed.

Try it tomorrow

After your next lesson, before anyone speaks to you, write your three lines: one thing that worked and why, one that did not and why, one change. Then pick a single action point and write it into the plan for the following lesson at the stage where it applies. One point, one lesson. Repeat.

Quick answers

Why does the trainee speak first in feedback?

Because a teacher who can see their own lesson accurately keeps improving after the course. Self-evaluation first builds that habit and makes the trainer's points easier to hear.

How many action points should I get after a lesson?

One or two. A list of six is complete but hard to act on, because nobody can change six habits in a week. Good trainers find the one or two points that cause most of the others.

What do CELTA trainers look for in teaching practice?

Whether aims were achieved, how language was clarified and checked, how clear instructions were, how much learners worked and spoke, how errors were handled, and whether the lesson was staged and timed well.

What if I disagree with the feedback?

Ask for the example rather than defending the lesson. If the trainer can show you the moment, you have something to work on; if not, the discussion itself usually clarifies what they meant.

How should I give feedback to other trainees?

Describe a specific moment, explain its effect on learners, and suggest one thing to try. Stay with what you saw and heard rather than what you would have done.

Check your understanding

5 short questions. No account needed, no score, and nothing you choose or write is saved or sent anywhere.

  1. 1 In well-run post-lesson feedback, who usually speaks first?
    Show the answer (no automatic checking)

    Answer: C. Self-evaluation first builds the habit of seeing your own lesson accurately, which keeps you improving after the course ends.

    By Lumina Trainers

  2. 2 How many action points are most useful after one lesson?
    Show the answer (no automatic checking)

    Answer: A. Nobody can change six habits in a week. Good trainers find the one or two points that cause most of the others.

    By Lumina Trainers

  3. 3 Which piece of feedback is most useful?
    Show the answer (no automatic checking)

    Answer: B. Precise feedback names what happened, so the teacher can repeat it. Vague praise is pleasant but hard to act on.

    By Lumina Trainers

  4. 4 Write a three-line self-evaluation of a lesson you taught recently.

    Show a suggested answer

    For example: “Worked: pairs spoke for four minutes in the freer practice without me, because the task had a clear outcome. Did not work: learners misunderstood the gap-fill instructions, because I explained but did not demonstrate. Change: next time I will demonstrate with one learner and ask one ICQ.” Yours should describe what learners did, why, and one change.

    Suggested answer by Lumina Trainers

  5. 5 A trainer tells you that you echoed learner answers a lot, and you do not agree. How would you respond?

    Show a suggested answer

    Ask for the example: “Could you show me when?” Listen to the end before replying. If the trainer can show you the moment, make it an action point and plan how to react without repeating. If not, the discussion usually clarifies what they meant. Focus on evidence, not on defending the lesson.

    Suggested answer by Lumina Trainers

Ahmed Bin NasserCELTA Tutor & Teacher Trainer | Lumina